Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

Are noise-cancelling headphones enough when a borrowed garden tool calls for hearing protection?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

A neighbour in the US has offered to lend me a powered garden tool. Its instructions call for hearing protection. When I asked about that, he offered his ordinary noise-cancelling headphones and said, 'You can hardly hear anything with these on.'

I couldn't find a noise reduction rating on the packaging he showed me. I haven't used the tool. NIOSH's hearing-protection guidance says active noise cancellation should not be treated as hearing protection unless the device is labelled with an NRR. It also explains that choosing and fitting protection matters; a label alone doesn't determine the protection a person gets.

How can I pause the borrowing arrangement until I have appropriate equipment without insulting the headphones he likes? I am grateful for the offer, but I don't want my first use of the tool to double as a test of whether the sound merely seems quieter.

Discussion

5 community replies

The headphones can be useful for the purpose he bought them for without being established as suitable hearing protection for this task. You can explain that distinction without calling them poor quality.

'It sounds quiet' isn't the check described in the NIOSH guidance. Follow up on the tool's instructions and suitable hearing protection before starting, rather than testing the combination on yourself.

You have already found that fit and selection matter. Don't turn finding an NRR marking on a different product into a complete answer about this equipment and your exposure.

Could you thank him for the loan offer and postpone collecting the tool while you sort out the necessary protection? That would avoid arriving for the job and feeling pressured to use whatever is there.

Exactly: you can leave the offer open while making the preparation your own task. If you can't arrange appropriate equipment, say you won't use the tool for now. His willingness to lend it doesn't require either of you to certify an uncertain substitute.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours