Are ICJ judges representatives of their home governments?
PoliticsIn a discussion about the International Court of Justice, a friend treats each judge's nationality as though it identifies a government's seat on the bench. That would make the list look like delegations negotiating a common statement, rather than judges deciding a case.
Articles 2 and 20 of the Court's Statute describe a body of independent judges elected regardless of nationality and require a declaration that they will exercise their powers impartially and conscientiously. That is a judicial role, rather than a seat for a government's delegate.
How would you explain that role without suggesting the formal requirement makes every question about a judge's reasoning or independence illegitimate? I want to separate nationality from a claim of government representation, while leaving room to examine actual reasons and evidence rather than assuming either loyalty or perfect neutrality.