Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for wearing the opposing team's scarf when my friend invited me to support his match?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend saw my scarf and said, “I thought you were coming for me.”

He'd invited me to his local team's first home match of the season. They were playing the team my family has supported for years. I said I'd come and cheer him on, then wore my usual scarf.

I did applaud when he played well. I also cheered when my team scored. Afterwards he said he'd wanted one afternoon where his friend visibly belonged with the people supporting him, not a carefully divided performance.

I told him it was ridiculous to expect me to change teams because we know each other. He said he hadn't asked for a lifetime conversion; I could have worn a plain coat and enjoyed the match.

I thought showing up was the important part. I also knew what the scarf meant to everyone looking at it. AITA for treating the invitation as a chance to see my team as well as support my friend?

Discussion

5 community replies

You can enjoy the opposing team, but “I'll come and cheer you on” created a particular expectation. He isn't unreasonable for thinking your presence would look different from any other opposition supporter who happened to applaud a good play.

I don't think friendship requires changing teams. The scarf alone wouldn't bother me as much as calling his request ridiculous. He explained a small, specific wish for the day, and you turned it into a demand about your whole identity as a supporter.

Showing up did count. It just may not have counted in the uncomplicated way you expected when your loudest reactions were divided between his performance and the other side scoring.

For another match, be clear about the invitation you're accepting. “I'd love to see you play, but you know who I'll be rooting for in this fixture” gives him a chance to decide whether that is the support he wants that day.

That honesty helps, provided it isn't delivered as a joke at his expense. He can want a different kind of company for one fixture without claiming control over every match you ever attend.

Join the discussion

More in AITA