Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for washing my brother's lucky sports socks after he asked me not to?

AITA category photographAITA

My brother opened his overnight bag, saw the clean socks and said, “You promised to leave those alone.”

He was staying with me before a match. He calls the socks lucky and hadn't wanted them washed during a run of games. I'd said I wouldn't touch the bag.

Later, while doing laundry, I decided it was silly to leave them sitting there when I could wash them with everything else. I didn't like the smell and thought he'd appreciate having them clean once it was done.

He was furious. I told him the match would still be his to play and he shouldn't be so attached to a pair of socks. He said I wasn't being asked to believe in them; I was being asked to keep my word.

I could have asked him to move the bag or kept it in another room. Instead I turned an offer of a place to stay into permission to fix something he'd asked me to leave. AITA?

Discussion

5 community replies

YTA. The promise was clear, and washing them wasn't necessary to keep hosting him. You had a smell problem you could have raised; you chose a solution you knew he'd refused.

You don't need to agree about luck to respect somebody's belongings. Arguing about whether the socks matter to the match avoids the agreement you actually broke.

The line about appreciating them once they were clean is doing a lot of work. He told you what he wanted before you did it. His later reaction wasn't missing information you had no way to obtain.

Apologise for overriding the request without adding a lecture about what should matter to him. The practical lesson for another visit can be where the bag goes.

Yes. A storage arrangement would address your home without requiring him to adopt your view of the socks. Don't make a new invitation conditional on his admitting the wash was secretly a favour.

Join the discussion

More in AITA