Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for warning my sister's partner about the puppy she planned to bring home as a surprise?

AITA category photographAITA

My sister asked me to keep a birthday present secret. I agreed before she told me the present was a puppy for the home she shares with her partner.

He has talked about wanting a dog. He has also said, in conversations I've been part of, that he wants to wait until after their move next year. She thought seeing the puppy would change his mind. She expected them to share the care, rather than treating it as solely her dog.

I told her this was something to discuss before bringing an animal home. She said I didn't know their relationship well enough to decide what he'd welcome. I said I couldn't keep this particular surprise and gave her until the following evening to tell him herself.

She didn't. I contacted him, and he told her he wasn't ready to agree. No puppy had been collected yet.

She's angry that I broke my promise and took away her chance to make him happy. I think the initial promise didn't cover helping her bypass a decision he'd said he wanted to postpone.

AITA for telling him after warning her I would?

Discussion

5 community replies

You agreed to keep a present secret before knowing it involved a shared household decision. Telling her promptly that you couldn't keep this secret was a reasonable way to revisit that promise.

Her partner had already expressed a wish to wait, according to the conversations you describe. Hoping a puppy would change his mind meant the surprise was doing work that a discussion should have done first.

You gave her a chance to tell him herself, and you acted before a puppy came home. I'd keep the explanation focused on those choices rather than accusing her of not caring about him or the animal.

The narrator isn't one of the partners. I worry about making yourself the referee of what another couple is allowed to surprise each other with.

They did intervene, which deserves more thought than saying a promise no longer counts. Here, though, the partner had stated a time frame, and the sister hoped the surprise would overcome it. That's a concrete reason to warn him, rather than a general license to manage the couple.

Join the discussion

More in AITA