Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for using my restaurant voucher as part of my own share of our group bill?

AITA category photographAITA

Our equal shares came to $25 each. I used a $20 voucher and paid $5 in cash. The other three people each paid $25.

I'd won the voucher in a local raffle. When we were choosing a restaurant, I said, “I've got a voucher for that place.” I meant I could use it on my meal. Two friends say they thought it would reduce the table's total before we divided the bill.

The restaurant accepted it, so the disagreement is only between us. They say I spent less cash while enjoying the same dinner and should have shared the benefit of something I'd received for free. I see the voucher as something I brought, like birthday money I could have spent alone.

I didn't promise to treat anyone. I also didn't explain my plan until the bill arrived, after mentioning the voucher as a reason to choose the place.

AITA for counting its value toward my own share?

Discussion

5 community replies

Using your voucher for your share seems fair. The confusion came from mentioning it while choosing a restaurant without explaining what you were offering.

They aren't wrong to have imagined a table discount, but that assumption doesn't mean you intended one. I'd acknowledge the mixed message and be explicit before the next meal.

Explain the plan before choosing the venue: “I'm planning to use my voucher for my own meal; does the place still work for everyone?” That gives people a real choice about the price, rather than a surprise at the bill.

The others may have chosen the restaurant partly because they thought their meals would cost less. That reliance matters even if nobody meant to make a promise.

If someone said beforehand that the voucher would make their shares cheaper and the narrator let that pass, it would matter. The post doesn't say whether anyone voiced the assumption. An expectation nobody mentioned differs from one the narrator had a chance to correct.

Join the discussion

More in AITA