Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for turning off the main light in a shared hotel room when my friend still wanted to read?

AITA category photographAITA

At eleven I turned the room's main light off. My friend turned it back on.

We were sharing a twin room for a weekend away. I wanted to sleep; she wanted another hour with her book. We hadn't discussed bedtimes when choosing to share.

The bedside lamp on her side still shone toward my bed. She offered to use it instead of the main light, and I said I'd prefer no lights at all. She replied that sharing a room didn't mean she had to go to bed when I did.

I told her she could read downstairs. She said she didn't want to spend the end of the evening alone in the lobby after paying half for a room. I said sleeping was the basic purpose of having the room.

She eventually put the book away. The next morning she said I'd treated my preference as the default and hers as something to do elsewhere. I said I hadn't wanted to control her evening; I'd wanted to close my eyes without the light.

We're now discussing whether to get separate rooms for another trip. AITA for deciding the lights should go out when the other person sharing the cost wasn't ready?

Discussion

5 community replies

Wanting to sleep at eleven was reasonable. It didn't automatically settle the shared room's bedtime, particularly when neither of you had discussed the difference beforehand.

She offered the bedside lamp, which was an attempt to reduce the conflict. You may still have found it too bright, but acknowledge that offer rather than describing her as insisting on the main light all night.

'Sleeping is the basic purpose' sounded like a rule that made your use of the room more legitimate than hers. Both of you were trying to use a room you'd agreed to share, at an hour you hadn't agreed to regulate.

Separate rooms on a future trip could be a practical response to incompatible evenings, rather than a verdict that one of you is an inconsiderate friend.

That framing would help. It lets them discuss the cost and preferences before booking instead of turning another eleven o'clock disagreement into a test of friendship. For this trip, the narrator can still acknowledge making the decision unilaterally.

Join the discussion

More in AITA