Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for throwing away my aunt's stew after it sat out overnight without asking her first?

AITA category photographAITA

I emptied the stew into the food-waste bin while clearing my aunt's kitchen. When she came back, she asked where tomorrow's lunch had gone.

She'd left the cooked meat stew on the kitchen counter overnight, and confirmed it hadn't been refrigerated or kept hot. It was at room temperature when we went to bed and still there in the morning. I used the FDA's guidance on perishable leftovers, which says to discard perishables left at room temperature for more than two hours.

My aunt thought reheating it would be enough. I said I wouldn't eat it, then went ahead and discarded the whole pot while she was upstairs. I could have called to her before doing it.

She says declining my portion was my choice, but destroying food she'd cooked for herself was a separate decision. I offered to replace the ingredients. She said the point was being consulted, not getting a grocery refund.

I still wouldn't serve or eat it. AITA for treating the disposal decision as mine to make?

Discussion

5 community replies

The linked guidance supports discarding the stew after the storage conditions you describe. It doesn't mean a conversation with your aunt was impossible. She was upstairs, and you knew she disagreed.

I'd apologize for disposing of it behind her back, while being clear you won't eat or serve food you're declining on that safety basis. Those are two different decisions you made.

Replacing ingredients recognizes a cost, but not the time she spent cooking or the lost chance to speak before it went in the bin. Ask what practical repair she'd appreciate without reopening whether you should have eaten it.

I can understand not wanting to leave food there for someone to eat when you believe it should be discarded. Asking might only have led to an argument and the stew staying.

It might have. But avoiding a likely disagreement isn't the same as lacking time to consult her. The narrator could have stated the FDA guidance and refused involvement in serving it, rather than silently taking over the whole decision.

Join the discussion

More in AITA