Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for telling our guests the barbecue was off before my brother and I agreed on a backup plan?

AITA category photographAITA

Rain started before we'd lit the charcoal. My brother suggested moving the grill into my garage and keeping the big door open. I said no.

We'd planned an afternoon barbecue at my house. He'd bought much of the food and driven over early to help. I offered to cook a different meal in the kitchen, but he said the whole point was grilling together and that I was dismissing a workable solution.

I showed him Health Canada's carbon monoxide prevention guidance, which says not to operate charcoal-burning outdoor equipment inside a garage. The grill remained unlit.

He stopped arguing for the garage. What upset him next was my telling the other guests the barbecue was off before he and I had finished discussing whether we should postpone or serve something else. Some people then made other plans.

He says I used a safety issue to take over every decision about an afternoon we'd organized together. I think I needed to tell people promptly that the advertised plan had changed.

AITA for sending that message myself?

Discussion

5 community replies

The garage refusal was right. The later message is a separate question: did you say the gathering was canceled, or that the grill wouldn't be used? Those would give guests quite different information.

He had accepted the safety limit by then. I'd acknowledge the work and food he contributed and the fact that he was still discussing another plan when you announced a decision.

“We can't grill today; we're sorting out an indoor meal or a new date” would have warned guests without closing every option. You could have sent that together once the unsafe suggestion was off the table.

It's the narrator's house. They should be able to decide they don't want to host a different event from the one they'd planned.

Certainly, if that was their decision. But the post says they offered to cook another meal and mainly wanted to update people promptly. That leaves room to admit the cancellation message was broader than the decision they'd actually reached.

Join the discussion

More in AITA