Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for telling my sister that seeing her life helped me decide not to have children?

AITA category photographAITA

“Watching your weekends is part of why I don't want that life,” I told my sister. She stopped asking questions and left the table.

She'd been asking again when my partner and I would have children. I said we didn't want to. She said we were concentrating on the difficult bits and would understand the good parts once we became parents.

I tried saying our decision wasn't a criticism of hers. She kept asking what had made us so certain, and I eventually pointed to how little time she says she has for herself. I'd heard those complaints during private conversations when she was tired and wanted to talk.

She says I turned moments of trust into evidence that her life was something to avoid. I said I was answering the question she wouldn't stop asking, not claiming she regretted her children.

I still don't want to explain or defend our decision at family meals. AITA for giving an honest example when she pressed for one?

Discussion

5 community replies

She should have accepted the answer about your own plans. Using her private complaints as the example still made this more personal than it needed to be.

“I'm not discussing our reasons further” would have been a firm answer. You didn't need to persuade her the decision was sensible by evaluating the life she already has.

Tell her you don't assume she regrets her children, and apologize for using things she'd shared while tired. Separately, ask her to stop treating your decision as an unfinished debate.

I can understand finally giving a blunt answer when someone keeps rejecting the gentler ones. She asked what influenced the decision.

That explains why the exchange became sharp. It doesn't make private disclosures the only available answer. The narrator can own that choice while keeping the decision about children firmly outside further family debate.

Join the discussion

More in AITA