Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for telling my partner's mother we aren't planning to have children?

AITA category photographAITA

His mother said, “You'll understand when you two have a baby.” I replied, “We aren't planning to.”

My partner and I have discussed it and both decided we don't want children. He'd asked me to let him tell his mother in his own time. I agreed, but that was months ago. Meanwhile she keeps talking to me about future grandchildren, and I keep trying to redirect the conversation.

This time he was in the kitchen when she said it. I didn't plan an announcement. I was tired of smiling through a future we'd already decided against.

He says I'd agreed he could handle his own mother, and my answer made him walk into a conversation he'd specifically said he wasn't ready for. I said waiting had meant I was being asked to help her assume something untrue whenever she raised the subject.

He hasn't asked me to change my answer. He's upset about the timing and about my speaking for both of us while he wasn't there. AITA for answering directly?

Discussion

5 community replies

You shouldn't have to keep participating in assumptions about your own future indefinitely. But you did agree to wait, then changed that arrangement without telling him. Both parts belong in the conversation now.

His preferred timing affected you every time his mother brought up a baby. “I'll handle it” needed some account of what you were supposed to say meanwhile, especially after months had passed.

You answered a comment about you, not a private question about his medical history or somebody else's plans. I wouldn't treat your own decision as something he alone gets to announce. The joint wording is still worth discussing.

Before the next visit, agree on what each of you will actually say if she raises it again. Don't make another plan that relies on the subject somehow not coming up.

And the answer can't be just “keep smiling until I'm ready” unless you're willing to do that. He can choose how much of his own thinking to explain; you need wording you can honestly use about yours.

Join the discussion

More in AITA