Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for telling my friend's child the tooth fairy was a story during a sleepover?

AITA category photographAITA

"Are you putting the coin under my pillow?" the six-year-old asked.

His mother had left a coin with me and asked me to put it there once he was asleep. He was staying overnight with my child. I agreed without thinking much about the story around it.

When he asked directly, I said his mum usually did it and I was helping for the night. He asked whether that meant there wasn't a fairy. I said it was a game grown-ups played to make losing a tooth special.

He wasn't upset at the time. The next morning he told his mother, who was upset with me. She says I agreed to a familiar family ritual and then took away something she wanted to explain herself.

I said I didn't want to answer a direct question with something I didn't believe. She replied that I could have suggested he ask her, rather than settling it at my kitchen table.

I hadn't intended to make a statement about how she raises him. I also hadn't asked what she wanted me to say if he was awake and curious. AITA for giving the direct answer after accepting the overnight favor?

Discussion

5 community replies

You accepted more than handing over a coin in an ordinary exchange. His mother had explained where and when to put it, which gave you context for the game she wanted to continue. That makes her surprise understandable.

You weren't obliged to invent an elaborate account you were uncomfortable telling. But redirecting the question to his mother was an available response that wouldn't have required making the family's decision yourself.

His calm reaction at the table doesn't settle how his mother feels about losing the chance to have that conversation. Don't use the absence of tears as proof that there was nothing for her to object to.

Had you realized before the sleepover that you wouldn't go along with the story if asked? If so, that was a limit to explain when accepting the coin, not after the child had received your answer.

If the limit only became clear in the moment, the narrator can still acknowledge handling it without checking. Future overnight favors can include a brief conversation about what the parent expects, without turning every family game into a debate about who values honesty.

Join the discussion

More in AITA