Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for spending Christmas at home instead of visiting either set of parents?

AITA category photographAITA

My partner and I told both families we're spending Christmas Day at our own home this year. My mother asked what she had done wrong.

For the last few years, we've divided the day between the two households. Nothing terrible happens. We like seeing everyone, but we spend much of the day watching the time and leaving one meal to reach the next. This year we want to cook together, stay in comfortable clothes, and have no departure deadline.

In summer, my mother asked whether she should make the usual dessert and I said, “Probably!” We hadn't made our home plan then. We told everyone about the change before she'd bought food or organized the meal, and we offered visits on other days that week.

She says Christmas Day itself is the point, and she had already been looking forward to having us. My partner's parents are disappointed too, although they accepted another date. My brother says making both families sad just so we can sit on our own sofa is selfish.

This isn't a protest against anyone, and it isn't that we can't afford the travel. We want one Christmas that feels like ours. AITA for choosing that when both invitations are loving ones?

Discussion

5 community replies

NAH for wanting the day at home, and NAH for parents feeling sad about a change they hadn't expected. The sadness doesn't automatically mean you should reverse it. You gave notice and offered time together that week.

Own the “probably” about dessert. It gave your mother a reason to picture the usual day, even though you hadn't made a firm plan. I'd acknowledge that before discussing the alternative visit. She may need time to feel disappointed without every conversation becoming a new attempt to change your mind.

You don't need a family feud to want an unhurried Christmas with your partner.

Could you invite both sets of parents to yours for part of the day? It might give you the home setting without leaving everyone out.

That would solve the travel but could recreate the timed meal and hosting work they want a break from. An invitation makes sense only if they want to host. Their offered visits on other days are already a way to see the families.

Join the discussion

More in AITA