Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for showing my list of family favours after my sister said I never help?

AITA category photographAITA

When my sister said I never did anything for the family, I opened the note where I keep track and read out the last few entries.

There were airport lifts, helping with a move and setting up two parties. I started the list because I kept leaving family conversations feeling as though I'd imagined being useful. It has dates and what I did, not a tally of what everyone else has done.

My sister said keeping a list made every favour look like something I'd been saving up to collect on. I said I wasn't asking to be paid back; I wanted her to stop saying never.

I read it out in front of our parents. They now feel their requests may be recorded for a later argument. I understand why that feels different from simply remembering that I helped with a move.

AITA for using the list to challenge a sweeping accusation, rather than letting it pass again?

Discussion

5 community replies

The list was relevant to the word “never.” It doesn't make your help insincere. But producing a dated record can surprise people who thought you were describing a relationship, not keeping an account ready for a dispute.

Keep the correction narrow. Your entries show things you did; they don't establish who contributes most or what support other people give when you're not there.

You can tell your parents that remembering your own effort isn't a demand for repayment. They may still dislike being in the note, and you can hear that without accepting that every entry proves the favour was fake.

Ask your sister to describe the actual help she feels is missing instead of saying you never do anything. That gives you something specific to agree to, decline or discuss.

Yes. A more precise request could change the conversation from defending your entire history to deciding what you can offer now. Don't let the list become a reason nobody may ever ask for something different.

Join the discussion

More in AITA