Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for sending my friend my share after she insisted dinner was her treat?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend paid the dinner bill while I was in the bathroom. When I got home, I transferred her the cost of my meal. She sent it back with “Can you please just let me do something nice?”

She earns more than I do and has paid for our last few meals out. I can afford my own food, but I don't choose the expensive places she likes as often. She usually says she's inviting me and wants to treat me. She hasn't asked for favors in return or mentioned the money in an argument.

I still feel uncomfortable being treated repeatedly. Before this dinner I said, “I'm happy to come, but I want to pay for myself.” She said we could sort it out there, then paid without me. I sent my share partly to hold that line and partly because I didn't want another big thank-you conversation.

She says I make her generosity feel suspicious, as though she's keeping a secret ledger. I told her I prefer meeting for something we both pay for comfortably. She heard that as me saying our dinners have been a burden.

AITA for returning the money when she clearly intended a gift?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA. You raised paying for yourself before the meal. Paying while you were away didn't settle that disagreement. A gift can be kindly intended and still be something the recipient doesn't want to keep accepting.

Nothing here suggests a secret ledger. Don't accuse her of keeping one just because repeated treats make you uncomfortable.

For the next invitation, choose the place together within a budget you're comfortable paying. If she specifically wants to treat you to somewhere pricier, decide whether you want that before going. She may need to accept that some dinners she can easily afford aren't dinners you want as gifts.

Sending money may feel to her like returning a present unopened. I'd acknowledge that she was trying to include you in places she enjoys, especially if she has never used paying as leverage.

That's a fair acknowledgment, but this dinner had a conversation before it. She knew the narrator wanted to pay. The kind intention is worth recognizing; so is the choice she overrode.

Join the discussion

More in AITA