Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for saying “I hope so” when my friend wanted me to say she'd get the promotion?

AITA category photographAITA

The evening before her promotion interview, my friend said, “Tell me I've got this.” I said, “I really hope so.”

She asked me to say she would get it, just for tonight. I replied that neither of us knew who else was being interviewed. She put down her practice notes and said she hadn't asked me to assess the competition.

She'd spent the evening at my flat going through examples from her work. I helped her practise answers, and I do think she has strong reasons to apply. But I couldn't honestly say the job was hers when someone else would be choosing.

She says “you've got this” would have meant I believed in her, not that I possessed inside information. I told her I was rooting for her, but that came after I'd explained twice why I couldn't promise an outcome. She went home saying I'd made her feel foolish for needing encouragement.

I don't want support to depend on saying things I can't know. I also realise my careful wording became the main event when she was already nervous. AITA for sticking with “I hope so” instead of giving her the reassurance she asked for?

Discussion

5 community replies

You didn't have to guarantee the promotion. Once she explained that she wanted encouragement, though, repeating that other candidates existed added nothing useful. “I believe you can do this interview well” would have answered the need you were actually hearing.

Your friend was also asking for a particular sentence after you offered support in your own words. It isn't fair to make that sentence the only acceptable proof of friendship. Both of you could have left room for encouragement that didn't feel false to you.

The evening of practice counts as support. It would still be reasonable to apologise for turning her final request into a correction. That apology needn't include pretending you know the hiring result.

“You've got this” can mean different things to different people. Before the next big interview, ask whether she wants another practice run, encouragement, or a distraction. You don't need to settle how literally every supportive phrase should be read while she's packing up her notes.

I'd keep that conversation light. If it becomes a form she has to complete before you can be warm, the same problem will return. You already know enough to say something specific you believe, like that she'd worked hard on her examples and you were glad she went for it.

Join the discussion

More in AITA