Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to undo my friend's character's death in our storytelling game?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend asked me to change the ending of our last game session. His character had died, and he didn't want to continue unless we brought her back.

I run a small tabletop storytelling game with rules we agreed together. We said character deaths would remain part of the story, and everyone would have the option to make a new character. Another player did that earlier in the campaign.

My friend chose a risky action, we used the agreed dice roll, and it went badly. I didn't invent a special penalty or take control of his character. But he'd spent months developing her, and he says agreeing to a rule at the start didn't prepare him for how losing that story would feel.

I offered to help introduce a new character and give him time before the next session. He wants this character back. He says I'm choosing a tidy rule over keeping a friend in the group.

I don't want him to leave, but changing this outcome would also change what we told the earlier player was permanent. AITA for saying the ending stays?

Discussion

5 community replies

NAH about the disappointment or your reluctance to change the rule for one person. He may find this style of game less enjoyable than he expected. You can take that seriously without promising to restore the character.

Talk to the earlier player before assuming what changing the rule would mean to them. They might object, or they might welcome a different approach. Either way, don't speak for their feelings.

A break from the campaign could be a real option rather than a threat or punishment. Let him decide whether making a new character sounds enjoyable once the immediate disappointment settles.

I'd rather revisit a game rule than lose a friend from the table. Rules can be changed when people discover an activity isn't working as intended.

They can, but that should be a group decision about the game going forward, including how to treat earlier outcomes. A private exception offered under pressure could leave the same fairness problem waiting for the next loss.

Join the discussion

More in AITA