Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to tell my friend how I voted after she lost our club election?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend asked whether I'd voted for her. I said I wanted to keep my ballot private.

It was an election for a role in our hobby club, with anonymous ballots. I voted for another candidate. My friend had talked through her plans with me, and I'd wished her luck, but I hadn't promised her my vote or publicly endorsed her.

She says the privacy answer tells her all she needs to know, and she'd rather I admitted I hadn't backed her than hid behind the ballot. I said I didn't want friendships to come with a requirement to report votes.

What complicates it is that I did have concerns about one of her proposals. I raised them while we talked, but she may have heard the conversation as help preparing to win rather than a reason I might choose someone else.

AITA for keeping the answer private when she is asking about support from a friend, not an official record?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA for declining to report your vote. She can ask about your support, but helping her think through ideas didn't automatically promise a particular ballot.

Don't lie and say you voted for her to repair the friendship. That would give her reassurance based on something you know isn't true and make a later conversation harder.

Her disappointment may be about believing the preparation meant you supported her candidacy. You can acknowledge that possible misunderstanding without opening the ballot or claiming you never encouraged her at all.

Be clear about what you did and didn't offer: you listened, discussed her ideas and wished her well. If you want to keep the vote private, repeat that answer rather than supplying increasingly elaborate hints.

Yes. A series of hints can become a disclosure while leaving her to do the uncomfortable work of naming it. Either keep the boundary plainly or choose to tell her; don't make her solve it as a puzzle.

Join the discussion

More in AITA