AITA for refusing to promise my best friend we'd spend every future birthday together?
AITAMy best friend said, “Promise we'll still do this when we're old.” I said I hoped so, but couldn't promise every birthday.
We've celebrated together for years. This year she'd had a difficult time and wanted reassurance that the friendship wouldn't disappear as our lives changed. I'd already confirmed our plans for the next birthday.
She says I turned an affectionate moment into a list of possible reasons I might stop showing up. I mentioned partners, family plans and not knowing where either of us would live. She hadn't asked me for a calendar calculation.
I don't want to make a promise now that a future birthday will turn into a test of whether I've kept it. I also understand that she'd wanted to hear she would still matter, not all the ways the tradition could become inconvenient.
AITA for refusing the exact promise when I meant to reassure her about the friendship?