Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to give my matchmaking friend a detailed report on the date she arranged?

AITA category photographAITA

“Not a match for me, but thank you for introducing us,” I told my friend. She wanted a much fuller explanation.

She'd arranged a date with someone she thought I'd like. We had a pleasant evening, but I didn't want another date. I told him directly and haven't left him waiting for an answer.

My friend asked which comments had put me off and whether she could see our messages. I said I didn't want to turn a private evening into a review. She says she put her judgment behind the introduction and wants to understand what she missed.

There wasn't one alarming incident I needed to warn her about. I just didn't feel interested in continuing. She says that's too vague to learn anything from, and now she's embarrassed that she so confidently thought we'd get on.

AITA for declining more detail when she was the reason we met?

Discussion

5 community replies

The introduction didn't create a requirement to supply screenshots. You thanked her, gave her the outcome, and told the date himself. That covers the practical follow-up.

She may be treating your decision as a score for her matchmaking. Reassure her that a date not leading to another isn't necessarily evidence that she introduced two obviously incompatible people.

If you don't have a specific reason beyond not wanting to continue, don't manufacture one to satisfy the debrief. A list of criticisms could misrepresent a generally pleasant evening.

I don't think asking what didn't click is inherently gossip. A little feedback could help her understand what you look for.

An ordinary question can be fine. Here the answer was that nothing specific went wrong, and she wanted comments and messages to examine. Feedback becomes less useful when the person is pressed to produce a reason they don't actually have.

Join the discussion

More in AITA