Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to give my brother the ring Grandma gave me for his proposal?

AITA category photographAITA

My brother said I could finally put Grandma's ring to use. I asked him what he meant, and he said he'd like to propose with it.

Grandma gave it to me while she was alive. I wear it occasionally, though it spends most days in its box. My brother was close to her too. He says it would be meaningful to make it an engagement ring again and keep it in the family.

I said I wanted to keep it. He replied that I wasn't engaged, didn't wear it much, and might never have a wedding where it would play a part. I don't think the ring needs a wedding to justify my keeping it, but I also understand why he'd like a connection to her at his proposal.

He asked whether I'd at least lend it until they bought a different ring. I refused that too. I don't want to hand over something as an engagement ring while already planning the conversation where I ask for it back.

Now he says I'm keeping it in a drawer rather than letting it become part of a happy family occasion. AITA for saying no to both the gift and the loan?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA. You already use it as a connection to your grandmother. Occasional wear doesn't make that connection less meaningful than the proposal your brother has imagined.

The loan sounds like a recipe for a second painful conversation. If you aren't comfortable with the ring staying with them, it's clearer to say no now than to hope everyone will find returning an engagement ring easy later.

He was allowed to ask, and it makes sense that he'd like something of Grandma's involved. He lost me when he started ranking your use against a hypothetical future wedding. You don't need to prove you have an occasion important enough to keep it.

Does his partner actually want this ring, or has he decided that the family history makes it the right one? That's worth him finding out before treating your refusal as the only obstacle to the proposal he wants.

Even if his partner loves it, that wouldn't settle your answer. But it would at least make the discussion about something both of them want, rather than asking you to surrender it for a meaning your brother has assigned on everyone's behalf.

Join the discussion

More in AITA