Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to co-sign my friend's car loan after helping her choose the car?

AITA category photographAITA

“You helped me pick it, then left me stranded at the last step,” my friend said after I refused to co-sign her car loan.

We're in the US. I spent two Saturdays looking at cars with her, comparing what she liked and helping her stay within the monthly payment she had in mind. When she said she might need someone else on the loan application, I thought she meant a relative. I said, “Let's see what they offer,” rather than asking directly.

At the dealership she asked me to co-sign. I said I wasn't willing to take on a loan for a car I wasn't buying. She said it was only to help her qualify and she would make every payment. I hadn't promised to sign, and I haven't signed anything.

I later read the CFPB's explanation of co-signing a car loan: the co-signer takes on repayment responsibility if the borrower doesn't pay. That's more responsibility than I want.

She accepts that I can refuse but says I encouraged her to get attached to this car while knowing I wouldn't help. I could have clarified sooner. AITA for getting that involved and then saying no?

Discussion

5 community replies

Two Saturdays of car shopping aren't a promise to co-sign. Her disappointment doesn't fill in an agreement you never made.

“Let's see what they offer” was vague once she mentioned another person on the application. You can own that missed chance to clarify without agreeing that you caused the financing problem or need to solve it by signing.

When she says you wouldn't “help,” remind her what you did offer: time and a second opinion. That was real help, even though it didn't complete the purchase. You can acknowledge the vague conversation about the application without accepting that every earlier kindness committed you to the next request.

I'd stop suggesting alternative cars for the moment. She feels let down, and more shopping advice from you could sound like you're steering her again after declining the part she wanted.

That's sensible as a pause, though I wouldn't treat all future help as off limits. Ask whether she still wants a shopping companion once the misunderstanding is settled. If she does, make the financial boundary explicit before going.

Join the discussion

More in AITA