Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to be the photographer at our family picnic?

AITA category photographAITA

My cousin handed me her phone and said, “Can you do your usual?” I handed it back and said I wanted to be in the picnic this year.

I usually take most of the photographs at family gatherings. I enjoy photography, but I also end up calling people over, waiting for the children to look up and sorting everything afterwards. This time I'd left my camera at home. I'd mentioned that in the family chat, but hadn't explicitly said I wouldn't take pictures on anyone's phone.

My cousin asked for just one group shot. I said someone else could take it or set up a timer; I wasn't organising photographs that day. She took a quick picture herself, with a few people missing.

Now my aunt says there are hardly any photos of a day everyone made an effort to attend. She says a little warning would have let somebody else plan for it. I think the phones around the table were warning enough that I wasn't the only person capable of taking a picture.

AITA for refusing at the picnic instead of making my meaning clearer beforehand?

Discussion

5 community replies

You don't owe the family a full photo session every time you attend. But “I'm not bringing my camera” didn't clearly communicate “I'm not arranging even one phone picture.” Your aunt has a point about the warning, even if you were tired of the assumption.

Your cousin asked for one shot, and you heard the whole familiar job being handed back to you. Was she expecting you to gather everyone and sort the photos afterwards, or could you have taken the picture and handed back the phone? That difference matters.

The missing photos were a shared choice. Once you declined, any of the people who wanted them could have started organising a picture. They don't get to remain spectators all afternoon and assign you sole responsibility for the record.

Next time, be direct in the chat: you want to attend without being the organiser or photographer, so someone else should handle any planned group picture. That gives people a chance to respond before the moment arrives.

Yes, but a warning isn't a request for permission to take a day off. If nobody volunteers, the family may get fewer pictures. They can decide how much the photographs matter by deciding who will do the work.

Join the discussion

More in AITA