Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing to add my brother's old power bank to my battery-recycling trip?

AITA category photographAITA

I took my brother's rubbish bags to the bins after helping him clear a cupboard. Before leaving, I noticed an old power bank in one bag and gave it back to him.

We're in the US, and its label identifies a lithium-ion battery. I showed him the EPA's disposal guidance, which says these batteries and devices containing them should go to appropriate collection points rather than household rubbish or recycling bins.

He accepted that and asked me to take it on my planned trip to a battery collection point. I'd already checked that the site accepted power banks because I had one of my own to take. I said he should organize disposal of his things himself.

I've ended up handling several relatives' old electronics before and don't want that to become my job. But this was his first request, and he hadn't known about those earlier favors.

He says I added a separate errand to his week simply to establish a principle, when adding this item would barely change mine. AITA for drawing the line here?

Discussion

5 community replies

The disposal correction was useful. The separate favor is more debatable: you were already going somewhere that accepts this item, and he hadn't created the earlier pattern you're tired of.

You can decline an extra errand, but explain the existing family workload rather than speaking as though he knowingly tried to make you responsible for it. This was his first request.

A one-time yes with “please handle future items yourself” is an available option if you actually want to offer it. You don't have to make the boundary retroactive to every favor you've done for other relatives.

Small additions are exactly how someone becomes the family disposal service. I wouldn't dismiss the limit just because this item is convenient.

That's a reasonable concern about the pattern. It still helps to tell this brother that the pattern exists. The narrator could keep the no while acknowledging that he asked a straightforward question rather than knowingly pushing an established boundary.

Join the discussion

More in AITA