Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing my roommate's offer to buy our jointly made quilt for the cost of my fabric?

AITA category photographAITA

My roommate offered to pay back what I'd spent on fabric and take the quilt when she moves. I said I didn't want to sell my part of it.

We made it together over several months. Each of us bought fabric, chose blocks, and did sewing. It has been on the sofa in our shared flat. We never agreed what would happen when we stopped living together.

She sees reimbursing the materials as a clean way to settle it. I see an object we both made, not an expense I need refunded. I want to keep it too.

I haven't named a higher price because the point isn't to charge her for my time. I suggested we discuss taking turns having it, but she wants to finish dividing our belongings before she moves.

She says I'm making a household object into a reason we must stay entangled. I think she decided that paying for the raw materials should resolve a choice I hadn't agreed to make.

AITA for refusing the offer without proposing a price I'd accept?

Discussion

5 community replies

You're discussing two different things: reimbursing an expense and agreeing who keeps something you both value. Her offer answers the first without automatically resolving the second.

You don't need to invent an hourly rate if you aren't trying to sell your labor. Explain what having the finished quilt means to you, and ask what it means to her.

Taking turns is one possibility, but she can reasonably dislike an ongoing arrangement. Consider whether either of you would prefer another shared use or a mutually chosen place for it, rather than assuming continued joint possession will feel good.

I can see why she started with material costs. You both got enjoyment from making it, so treating the hours as a bill could become an argument nobody can settle.

That's a good reason to avoid a labor invoice, which the narrator isn't asking for. The remaining issue is consent to the buyout. A sensible first offer can still be one the other person doesn't want to accept.

Join the discussion

More in AITA