Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing my friend's research survey because I don't meet its criteria?

AITA category photographAITA

The first question asked whether I'd lived alone during the past year. I haven't. My friend told me to select yes and answer as though I had.

She's completing a dissertation and having trouble finding participants. She'd sent me the survey asking for help, and I assumed she meant either completing it if eligible or passing the invitation to someone who was.

I checked whether the questions were meant to be hypothetical. She said no, the study was about actual experiences, but I could imagine reasonable answers and nobody would know. I said I wasn't comfortable supplying a life I hadn't lived.

She says a friend could help her get over one final hurdle instead of making a point about being principled. I offered to share the invitation with people who might qualify, but she wanted a completed response before her deadline.

AITA for refusing a small task she says matters much more to her than to me?

Discussion

5 community replies

You offered the kind of help you could give honestly. She changed the request into asking you to claim experience you don't have.

Keep the refusal narrow: “I can't answer these as actual experiences.” You don't need to deliver a verdict on her entire dissertation or threaten to report her to make that point.

Ask her whether she wants help finding eligible participants before the deadline. If she doesn't, you can stop offering alternatives instead of trying to produce a version of the favor she'll accept.

Could she broaden the criteria with whoever supervises the project? People who have always lived with others might have perspectives worth including.

Possibly, if the study is changed to ask those people genuine questions about their own lives. That's different from selecting yes to a condition the narrator doesn't meet and inventing answers within the existing survey.

Join the discussion

More in AITA