Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for refusing my aunt's housewarming flowers at the door because I have a cat?

AITA category photographAITA

My aunt arrived with a bouquet labeled “stargazer lilies.” I thanked her, then said I couldn't bring it inside because of my cat.

She suggested putting it on a high shelf. I said I wasn't comfortable trying to manage it that way. The FDA's guidance on lilies and cats identifies stargazer lilies among those that are highly toxic to cats and advises against bringing them into a home with a cat.

The bouquet stayed outside with her while we talked. She eventually put it back in her car and came in without it. My cat remained indoors; there wasn't a known exposure.

What upset her was my saying, “The cat lives here; the flowers don't.” She'd chosen a large bouquet for my first home and thought I could show some regret about not keeping it. I thought I was making the limit clear after she'd suggested alternatives.

I offered to take a photo of us together instead, but she said I was treating a heartfelt present like a parcel delivered to the wrong address.

AITA for refusing it so firmly instead of trying to find a way to display it?

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep the refusal. Repair the sentence. “They're beautiful, and I'm sorry I can't keep them” would recognize the gift without agreeing to bring it inside.

This wasn't just a preference about flowers. The linked FDA guidance supports excluding these lilies from a cat's home. It also says to call a veterinarian or pet poison control center immediately if ingestion of lily material, pollen, or vase water is suspected.

She may have heard your line as “your gift doesn't belong here” rather than an explanation about the cat. Tell her what you appreciated about the gesture, especially choosing something for your first home.

Would offering to choose another bouquet together have helped? The photograph was kind, but it didn't really replace the thing she had spent time selecting.

It might help later if both want that. I'd avoid making a replacement purchase the price of accepting the refusal, though. They can enjoy the visit and acknowledge the disappointment without immediately finding another object.

Join the discussion

More in AITA