Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for putting out my mother's memorial candle before we left the house?

AITA category photographAITA

Mum was already by the car when I put out the candle beside Dad's photograph.

It was the anniversary of his death. She wanted the candle to burn through the evening, including while we went out for a family dinner. I was the last person inside and asked whether she wanted to stay home with it instead. She said no, but asked me to leave it lit.

I said I wasn't comfortable leaving the house empty with a candle burning. She pointed to its glass holder and said it would be fine. I put it out, locked up and told her what I'd done before we drove away.

The US Fire Administration's guidance says to extinguish candles when leaving a room or home. I stand by not leaving the flame unattended. What I regret is saying, "It's only a candle; we can light it again."

Mum said that, to her, keeping it burning had been part of how she wanted to mark the evening. Dinner went ahead, but she felt I had dismissed that meaning as well as changed the plan.

AITA for putting it out after she explicitly asked me not to?

Discussion

5 community replies

The US Fire Administration advises putting candles out when leaving the room or home. A glass holder isn't a reason to disregard that guidance. Declining to leave this flame unattended was a sensible precaution.

You offered the possibility of someone remaining home, and your mother declined. That matters to the immediate choice. It wasn't a dispute about whether she could light a candle while people were there with it.

For another anniversary, ask how she'd like to preserve the ritual while people are present, or whether she would choose a flameless alternative for the time everyone is out. Offer choices rather than replacing the ritual for her in advance.

'Only a candle' reduced the object to its practical function at the moment she was explaining its emotional one. You can regret that sentence without regretting extinguishing the flame.

Yes. Tell her you understood that it represented remembering Dad, even though you wouldn't leave it burning in an empty house. Relighting it together afterward could be offered as company, not as proof that her disappointment should vanish immediately.

Join the discussion

More in AITA