Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for putting more food on my friend's plate after she said she was finished?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend said she was full. I put another spoonful on her plate and said she didn't need to be polite.

In my family, the first refusal often means someone doesn't want to take too much. I thought I was showing her she was welcome to eat more. She repeated that she was finished, and I said she could leave it if she really didn't want it.

She did leave it. Afterwards she told me that having the extra portion put in front of her made her feel watched, as if I was judging whether she'd enjoyed the meal enough.

I wasn't trying to measure her appetite. But I'd answered a clear sentence as though I knew what she really meant better than she did. AITA for serving the extra food when she could simply have left it?

Discussion

5 community replies

YTA. She had already chosen to leave no more food on her plate. “You could leave it” gave her another refusal to make after you ignored the first one.

Your family's polite-refusal habit explains the mistake. It doesn't tell you what this friend meant. Once she said she was finished, you had a chance to use her words rather than the family script.

You don't need her to explain why she was full or how much she normally eats. The useful repair is acknowledging that you served more after she declined.

Next time, make the offer and let the answer settle it. You can leave extra food available without transferring it to someone's plate.

And don't keep refreshing the offer until the answer changes. A generous table can include people who are happy to stop eating while everyone else continues.

Join the discussion

More in AITA