AITA for publishing a mixed review of my friend's first novel?
AITAMy friend sent me a message saying, “I wish you'd told me before putting that online.” She meant the review of her novel on my small personal book blog.
I'd read the whole book. I liked the opening and the central friendship, but thought the middle repeated the same conflict and that the ending felt rushed. That's what I wrote. I also said at the start that I knew the author.
She'd asked whether I could help with the launch by sharing a review when I finished. I said yes. We didn't discuss whether I'd show it to her first. I usually publish my own opinions without sending drafts to authors, but she's also someone I have dinner with.
She says asking a friend to help launch a first book obviously means support, not a public critique at the moment she's most nervous about it. She would have welcomed the same points privately. I thought writing a considered review, including the things I liked, was a form of taking the book seriously.
I haven't removed it. I don't want to change an opinion to keep a friendship comfortable, but I may have treated her request as more detached than it was. AITA for publishing without a warning?