Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for publishing a mixed review of my friend's first novel?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend sent me a message saying, “I wish you'd told me before putting that online.” She meant the review of her novel on my small personal book blog.

I'd read the whole book. I liked the opening and the central friendship, but thought the middle repeated the same conflict and that the ending felt rushed. That's what I wrote. I also said at the start that I knew the author.

She'd asked whether I could help with the launch by sharing a review when I finished. I said yes. We didn't discuss whether I'd show it to her first. I usually publish my own opinions without sending drafts to authors, but she's also someone I have dinner with.

She says asking a friend to help launch a first book obviously means support, not a public critique at the moment she's most nervous about it. She would have welcomed the same points privately. I thought writing a considered review, including the things I liked, was a form of taking the book seriously.

I haven't removed it. I don't want to change an opinion to keep a friendship comfortable, but I may have treated her request as more detached than it was. AITA for publishing without a warning?

Discussion

5 community replies

A request for a review isn't a promise of praise. You read the book, explained your view and disclosed the friendship. She can dislike the review without being owed a more favourable version.

You agreed to help with a launch, not simply to read a book whenever you liked. I can understand why she expected you to flag that your review would be mixed before using it as the help you'd promised. That doesn't mean she should get to approve your opinions.

A warning and an approval process aren't the same thing. You could have said you liked parts of the book but had reservations, then clarified whether she still wanted your review as part of the launch. You wouldn't have needed to negotiate every criticism.

I'd leave out claims about what her request “obviously” meant on either side. You each relied on a different convention: she thought friendly promotion, you thought independent review. The useful conversation now is whether you can agree to keep future writing requests separate from the friendship.

That's useful for future requests, but don't use the ambiguity to avoid addressing this one. You can say you didn't anticipate how the launch framing would affect her expectations. That acknowledges the missed conversation without saying the review itself was dishonest or cruel.

Join the discussion

More in AITA