Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for pointing out a chip in a bowl my friend was selling before the buyer paid?

AITA category photographAITA

"There's a chip by the handle," I said, just as the buyer reached for her purse.

My friend was selling household things at a small yard sale. I was helping carry boxes and take payments. A bowl on the table had a visible piece missing from the edge. My friend had described it as a lovely serving bowl and asked $8, without mentioning the chip.

The buyer looked more closely and offered $6. My friend accepted. Afterward she asked why I'd stepped in when the buyer could inspect the bowl herself.

I said I didn't want someone paying and then noticing damage we hadn't mentioned. My friend said she'd priced it cheaply because of the chip and hadn't claimed it was perfect. She felt I'd implied she was trying to hide something.

I hadn't asked her whether the price already reflected the damage. I also don't think that would have told the buyer anything about why it was cheap.

The sale went through. The bigger cost seems to be that my friend now doesn't want me helping explain her items. AITA for speaking before giving her a chance to mention it herself?

Discussion

5 community replies

The price being low because of a chip wasn't information the buyer had. A brief, factual mention let her make a more informed choice. That doesn't require concluding your friend intended to mislead anyone.

Your friend may have felt publicly corrected while you thought you were simply helping with the sale. Explain that you were trying to prevent a later surprise, not making a statement about her character.

Since you were helping take payments, it was reasonable to care about what happened before money changed hands. Still, agree how to handle questions about her items if you help again, rather than discovering different expectations at the purse.

Did you say it in a neutral way, or as a warning that cut across what your friend was saying? The same useful information can land very differently depending on that moment.

If the delivery was pointed, apologize for that while keeping the information itself ordinary. The narrator doesn't need to retract a visible chip. They do need to avoid turning disclosure into a performance of being the only honest person at the table.

Join the discussion

More in AITA