Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for painting the same design for several friends' birthday gifts?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend thought the little mountain painting I gave her was unique. Then she saw a similar one at another friend's flat.

I painted four versions of the same scene for birthdays. Each has different colors and was painted separately. I didn't copy a finished picture onto prints. I also didn't tell anyone they had the only version.

When I gave hers, I said, “I made this for you.” She says that phrase implied something designed around her, rather than a design I was making for several people. She felt special at first and now feels like one name on a production list.

I chose the colors because they reminded me of a walk we'd taken. That part was personal, though the mountains were the same composition. I told her handmade gifts can involve repeated designs without becoming meaningless.

AITA for not mentioning the other versions when I gave it to her?

Discussion

5 community replies

NAH about the initial misunderstanding. You made her painting yourself, and she imagined exclusivity you hadn't promised. I can also understand the little disappointment of discovering a matching scene elsewhere.

Tell her about the colors and the walk. That's a specific reason you chose her version, and it says more than an abstract argument about how handmade gifts work.

If you're giving repeats in future, a casual “I've been painting a small series” might prevent the same confusion. You don't need to present it as a warning that the gift is less valuable.

I'd be disappointed too. “Made for you” sounds more personal than “made one in your colors from a design I'm repeating.”

It can sound that way, but personalization doesn't have to include a new composition every time. The colors tied to their shared walk were personal. Her disappointment can be acknowledged without treating the gift as a false claim to exclusivity.

Join the discussion

More in AITA