Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for painting over our children's height marks after they moved out?

AITA category photographAITA

The wall looks lovely. My husband won't look at it.

Our children are grown and have moved out. We'd agreed to turn their old playroom into a study. One strip of the doorframe had their heights marked in pencil, with names and dates. My husband asked me to leave that strip while we decided how to keep the record.

I left it through the first weekend of painting. A month later it was still the unfinished patch beside a room we'd otherwise changed. I'd taken a clear photograph and thought keeping the actual marks was delaying the point of making the room ours again. I painted over them while finishing the trim.

My husband says he wanted a say in whether the marks went, not simply a copy sent to his phone afterwards. I told him the photograph contained the same information. He said I knew that wasn't what he meant.

Neither child had asked us to preserve the doorframe. I keep reaching for that as a defence, but it was my husband who'd asked me to wait. I don't want every change to the house to require months of discussion. This one now seems to have become about whether I get to decide when he's finished being sentimental.

Discussion

5 community replies

YTA for overriding the specific agreement to leave that strip. The question wasn't whether the photograph was legible. You knew he hadn't yet agreed to replacing the physical record with an image.

A month of indecision can be frustrating when you're trying to finish a room. You could have asked for a decision by a particular weekend and discussed the options then. Painting first made the decision final before he knew the conversation had ended.

Leave the children out of your defence. Their not asking to preserve it doesn't answer the request your husband did make. He had his own memories attached to the marks.

Don't promise to recreate the original just to make the argument go away. A print of the photograph might be something to offer later, but first acknowledge that you removed the choice he thought you were still discussing.

Agreed. He may like a print eventually, or he may not. Let him have a reaction that isn't treated as another obstacle to finishing the study. A replacement display won't itself repair the decision you made without him.

Join the discussion

More in AITA