Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for not giving my dad the head of the table at dinner in my own home?

AITA category photographAITA

Dad picked up his place card and said, “Surely this one's mine,” pointing to the head of the table.

I'd put myself there. It was the first family dinner I was hosting in my new home. At my parents' house, Dad always takes that seat. I wanted this evening to feel like mine to host.

I told him my chair was convenient for getting to the kitchen. That was true, but it wasn't the whole reason. He offered to swap the whole arrangement around so I could still get out easily. I said no and put his card back at the side.

He says the change felt like a public lesson about his no longer being in charge. I hadn't intended a confrontation, but I had wanted the symbolic difference. AITA for keeping the seat instead of letting a familiar tradition continue?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA for choosing a different arrangement in your home. A family tradition can matter to him without requiring every host to reproduce it.

The kitchen explanation invited him to solve a practical problem that wasn't your main concern. Be honest that you wanted the chance to host from that place, rather than making him guess why his suggested swap still wasn't acceptable.

He's allowed to feel the change. That doesn't mean the dinner needed to be rearranged so he never experienced it. You can welcome him warmly from a side seat.

Don't insist the seat was meaningless if you chose it partly for what it meant. You can own the symbolism without presenting dinner as a contest over which adult is in charge.

Exactly. “I wanted to establish my own hosting tradition” is clearer than treating him as foolish for noticing a message you partly intended. It needn't mean you've stopped valuing him.

Join the discussion

More in AITA