Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for naming the friend who told me a rumour after promising I wouldn't?

AITA category photographAITA

I told our walking group where I'd heard the story about Alex quitting. My friend says I broke a promise to protect myself.

She'd told me Alex was leaving because he couldn't stand the organiser, then asked me not to say she'd told me. I agreed. Later I repeated it to another member as if it were settled. Alex heard about it and said he had never planned to quit.

By then, people were blaming a newer member who'd recently disagreed with the organiser. He denied starting the story. In the group chat I said that he hadn't told me anything, that I'd heard it from my friend, and that I was the one who'd passed it on without checking.

My friend says I could have owned my part without naming her. She also says she'd offered an impression of how Alex was feeling, not news for me to announce. I remember her saying he was leaving, but we spoke in person and I can't produce an exact record.

I didn't want the newer member taking the blame. I also didn't want everyone to think I'd invented the whole thing. That second reason was in there when I typed her name.

AITA for breaking the promise rather than saying only that I'd repeated an unconfirmed story?

Discussion

5 community replies

You could clear the newer member without naming another source: he hadn't told you, you repeated something you hadn't checked, and Alex says it isn't true. Your admission that you wanted to avoid looking like the inventor matters. You used the group chat to defend your reputation as well as his.

The promise wasn't a good reason to let someone uninvolved take the blame. But there was a gap between correcting that blame and posting your friend's name. Did anyone ask who told you before you supplied it? That would affect how necessary the disclosure actually was.

Your friend may have overstated a guess, and you may have turned a guess into an announcement. You don't need to settle whose memory of the first conversation wins before apologising to Alex for giving him an invented exit from the group.

Don't let this become a hunt for the person furthest back in the chain. The message you can correct directly is yours: you spoke as though you knew Alex's plans when you hadn't asked him.

That also means the correction shouldn't end with “but she told me.” You've already named her; repeating the attribution won't undo the first message. Make it clear that Alex's own account of his plans is the one the group should use.

Join the discussion

More in AITA