Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for moving my roommate's bird feeder to her side of our balcony?

AITA category photographAITA

I moved the bird feeder from above our drying rack to the corner where my roommate keeps her plant pots. She asked why I thought dropping the mess onto her things solved anything.

The feeder is hers. She enjoys watching the birds from the living room, and I like seeing them too. But I'd found droppings on clothes hanging beneath it and asked her twice to help sort out the arrangement. She said she'd find another spot and hadn't done it yet.

I moved it while she was out. I used its existing hook and didn't damage it. I chose that corner partly because it was away from the washing and partly because I thought the person who wanted the feeder should deal with the mess.

She says I could have temporarily taken it down and discussed a new location, rather than making a point with her plants. I said I'd already tried discussing it.

AITA for relocating it instead of waiting again?

Discussion

5 community replies

The laundry problem needed action. Choosing the spot partly so her belongings would be underneath turned the solution into a message. Own that part rather than pretending location was the only issue.

She said she'd deal with it and left the arrangement unchanged. You're not unreasonable for being fed up. A specific deadline would have been clearer than another open-ended promise.

You both enjoy the feeder, so talk about where it goes and who cleans the shared space around it. “Your hobby, your mess” doesn't quite describe the shared enjoyment you've mentioned.

I can see a case for taking it down temporarily, but I'd object if my roommate treated every delayed household task as permission to remove something I enjoy.

That's a fair concern about a general rule. Here there were repeated requests about clothes already getting dirty. A temporary pause while choosing a location would address that concrete problem without deliberately putting the mess over her possessions.

Join the discussion

More in AITA