Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for making a bad move in our cooperative game just to stop my friend directing my turn?

AITA category photographAITA

Daniel told me to save a card in our cooperative board game. I could see why he was right. I used it anyway, mostly because I was tired of him directing my turns.

There were four of us playing. Daniel knew the game best and had been telling everyone which cards to use and where to move. Twice I said I wanted to decide my own turn. He backed off briefly, then started again when he saw a mistake coming.

My move helped lose us the game. When he asked why I'd done it, I said, “Because apparently that's the only way I get a turn.” One friend laughed. The other said I'd used everyone's evening to make a point to Daniel.

Daniel says he'd have stopped if he'd known I was seriously annoyed. I think saying it twice should have counted. AITA for knowingly making the wrong move to get him to back off?

Discussion

5 community replies

ESH. Daniel wasn't listening, but you already understood the move and chose it to provoke him. That turned a disagreement between two people into a loss for all four. The friend who objected has a point independent of Daniel's behavior.

You did explain. Twice. Daniel doesn't get to erase those requests because you didn't announce your annoyance in the form he would have preferred.

Next session, I'd agree on a simple rule before opening the box: advice only when the active player asks. If Daniel can't enjoy that arrangement, this may be the wrong game for this particular group.

A cooperative game should allow imperfect moves. I worry that blaming you for the loss just gives Daniel a justification for taking over even more next time.

Imperfect moves belong in the game, yes. But the narrator says they understood the advice and acted mostly to make Daniel stop. I'd defend their right to make a sincere mistake while still criticizing a deliberate protest that used the team's remaining chances.

Join the discussion

More in AITA