Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for lending a borrowed tent to another friend after my own camping trip was canceled?

AITA category photographAITA

The tent came back clean and on time. Its owner is still annoyed that I wasn't the person who used it.

I'd borrowed it from a friend for a camping weekend. My plans fell through on Friday, and another friend asked whether he could use it for his own trip. I said yes. I checked it when he returned and gave it back by the original deadline.

The owner found out because I mentioned that my weekend had been spent at home. I explained who had used the tent, and she asked why I hadn't checked with her first. I said she'd already agreed to be without it for those days.

She says she lent it to someone whose habits she knew, not to anyone I happened to trust. I offered to take responsibility if a problem turned up, but she says this isn't a discussion about whether I can pay for damage.

AITA for treating the agreed borrowing period as something I could pass on?

Discussion

5 community replies

YTA. She agreed to lend it to you. The available dates were one part of that agreement, not the whole permission.

Returning it clean and on time matters, but it doesn't explain why you couldn't send a quick question before lending it onward. You changed who handled her equipment while keeping her out of the decision.

Tell her you understand the difference now, and don't defend the choice with another promise to pay for a hypothetical problem. She's asking to choose who borrows her things.

If the narrator was willing to take responsibility, I can understand seeing this as a harmless substitution. The owner still got what she expected back.

She got the tent back, but discovered a different arrangement had happened. Willingness to cover a problem doesn't substitute for letting her decide whether to accept that arrangement in the first place.

Join the discussion

More in AITA