Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for keeping our baby's name from my sister after accepting her apology for sharing earlier news?

AITA category photographAITA

"So you haven't really forgiven me," my sister said when I wouldn't tell her the name.

Last year I told her my partner and I were moving, and asked her to leave the announcement to us. She told our parents the same afternoon because she was excited. She apologized afterward, and I said I forgave her.

We are now expecting our first child and have chosen a name. We aren't sharing it with relatives yet. My sister asked privately, promising that this time she'd keep it to herself. I said I'd rather wait and tell everyone together.

She says the answer uses one mistake to keep her permanently outside my confidence. I told her forgiveness didn't mean I had to offer another secret on request. That sounded like a prepared slogan, and she said I was treating her as a lesson rather than a sister.

I do tell her other personal things. This particular announcement matters to both me and my partner, and neither of us wants an early family discussion of the name.

AITA for accepting the apology while still choosing a more cautious way to share this news?

Discussion

5 community replies

You aren't telling other relatives while singling her out. The plan is to share with everyone later. That is relevant to her claim that she is being kept uniquely outside the family news.

The earlier disclosure can affect what you feel comfortable sharing without making forgiveness dishonest. Still, explain the actual plan rather than relying entirely on a slogan about what forgiveness does or doesn't mean.

Your partner also has a stake in when the name is shared. Your sister's wish for a test of trust doesn't settle a choice involving another person's news.

She may be asking for reassurance that the mistake hasn't defined the whole relationship. You say you still confide in her about other things. Those examples might communicate that more gently than arguing over the word forgiven.

Yes, as long as the examples aren't presented as a tally of privileges she's been allowed to keep. The narrator can reassure her about the relationship while leaving this announcement on the agreed timetable. A secret needn't become the required evidence of reconciliation.

Join the discussion

More in AITA