Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for keeping a scarf from the donation bag my friend asked me to drop off?

AITA category photographAITA

“I thought that bag had gone to the charity shop,” my friend said when she saw me wearing her scarf. The rest of it had. I had taken the scarf out first.

She was clearing clothes before a move, and I offered to deliver two bags because I was driving past the shop. While putting them in my car, I noticed a scarf I had always liked. I kept it and dropped everything else off. I didn't ask because she was busy packing and I assumed something she was giving away was available to anyone who would use it.

She says she chose to donate those clothes and trusted me to do that job. She also said she might happily have given me the scarf if I had asked, which makes this feel like a bigger argument over a small omission. I told her it still went to someone who wanted it. She replied that I was congratulating myself for helping while quietly taking a perk.

I've offered to return it so she can donate it herself. She wants an acknowledgment before we discuss what happens to the scarf. AITA for thinking keeping it was within the spirit of getting rid of unwanted clothes?

Discussion

5 community replies

You were asked to deliver the bags to a charity shop. Wanting the scarf was understandable; quietly changing the delivery wasn't. YTA.

I don't think wanting the scarf was the problem. Quietly taking it meant she couldn't decide whether to give it to you, include it in the donation, or offer you something else. You treated her reason for clearing the clothes as irrelevant.

“I should have checked before taking something out of your bags.” That answers what she's asking for. Offering the scarf back answers a different question.

Her saying she would probably have given it to you is a reason to keep this proportionate. You handled it badly, but the scarf needn't become a test of whether you're a decent person. Apologize and let her choose where it goes.

Agreed on proportion, but she hasn't asked for a character confession. She's asking you to stop defending the shortcut. That seems a pretty small repair for someone who trusted you with the bags.

Join the discussion

More in AITA