Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for keeping a public memorial page for my friend after her sister asked me to close it?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend's sister asked me to take down the memorial page I'd made. She said the family wanted her life kept out of public view.

I'd posted two photos my friend and I had shared before, along with my own memories of our friendship. I hadn't discussed the page with her family first. I thought I was writing about a loss that belonged to her friends as well as her relatives.

Her sister doesn't say a particular sentence is wrong. She wants the whole page closed. I offered to remove the photos and leave only my writing. She said that still turned her sister into a public story at a time when the family wanted quiet.

I don't want to make their grief harder. I also feel uneasy being told that I can't write publicly about someone who was important to me. I haven't added anything since the request, but the page is still up.

AITA for wanting a compromise rather than closing it immediately?

Discussion

5 community replies

Your memories matter too. But a public page about someone who can't choose its audience deserves more care than assuming your friendship settles the question.

Ask what the family is worried about, while accepting they may not want a long debate right now. You might learn there's a specific concern your offer to remove photos doesn't address.

Keeping your writing privately for now would preserve it while giving both sides time. That doesn't have to be a declaration that your grief matters less or that you can never share anything again.

Family members aren't the only people with a relationship to someone who died. I worry about giving one relative complete control over how every friend remembers her.

Neither would I. The immediate question is this public page, made without a conversation, while the family is asking for quiet. A pause or narrower way of sharing can respect that request without granting permanent control over every memory.

Join the discussion

More in AITA