Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for keeping a café chair for a friend who was running late?

AITA category photographAITA

A man at the next table asked whether he could take the empty chair beside me. I said my friend would be there in a minute.

I didn't actually know that. She'd messaged that she was delayed, without giving a new arrival time. I wanted us to sit together and thought giving up the chair would mean another search when she arrived.

The man said someone in his group needed it now. I still refused. My friend arrived about twenty minutes later. By then his group had found another chair, but he'd come back once to ask whether I was still saving this one.

I told my friend I'd defended her seat. She said she appreciated wanting to sit together but wouldn't have expected someone else to wait on a delay I couldn't explain.

There wasn't a reservation or a stated rule we'd been given about holding chairs. AITA for keeping one place for a person I really was meeting?

Discussion

5 community replies

Holding a chair briefly for a friend isn't inherently unreasonable. The weak part was presenting an unknown delay as a minute, then relying on that story while someone had an immediate use for it.

Your friend being real didn't answer how long the other group should wait. You were comparing their present need with an arrival you couldn't predict.

The other group eventually finding a chair doesn't prove your choice was considerate at the time. You didn't know that solution would appear when you refused.

Don't turn the incident into a debt your friend owes you for defending her place. You chose to keep the chair, including the inaccurate assurance about when she'd arrive.

Exactly. Her delay created the situation, but you supplied the promise to the other table. You can be frustrated about waiting without making her responsible for how you dealt with the request.

Join the discussion

More in AITA