AITA for judging my friend's contest entry instead of stepping aside?
AITAMy friend saw the results and said, “I thought having you on the panel meant someone would understand what I was trying to do.”
I'd agreed to help judge a small photography contest at our community arts club. Three of us scored each entry against the same brief. I knew my friend's picture was hers, although names weren't displayed. I scored it below several others because I thought it didn't fit the brief as closely.
I hadn't told the organizers that we were friends. It seemed unnecessary because I wasn't planning to favor her. Now she says I overcorrected to prove I was impartial. She knows I'd praised the picture when she first showed it to me.
I liked it then and still do. Liking a picture isn't the same as choosing it for this particular contest. But I can see why being judged by someone she'd previously asked for encouragement felt strange, especially when I never explained that my role had changed.
AITA for judging her entry as I would anyone else's rather than stepping aside?