Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for judging my friend's contest entry instead of stepping aside?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend saw the results and said, “I thought having you on the panel meant someone would understand what I was trying to do.”

I'd agreed to help judge a small photography contest at our community arts club. Three of us scored each entry against the same brief. I knew my friend's picture was hers, although names weren't displayed. I scored it below several others because I thought it didn't fit the brief as closely.

I hadn't told the organizers that we were friends. It seemed unnecessary because I wasn't planning to favor her. Now she says I overcorrected to prove I was impartial. She knows I'd praised the picture when she first showed it to me.

I liked it then and still do. Liking a picture isn't the same as choosing it for this particular contest. But I can see why being judged by someone she'd previously asked for encouragement felt strange, especially when I never explained that my role had changed.

AITA for judging her entry as I would anyone else's rather than stepping aside?

Discussion

5 community replies

Not giving her a prize was reasonable. The missed step was telling the other judges you recognized an entry and knew its photographer, so they could decide how to handle that.

She may be disappointed, but your earlier praise wasn't a promise about the contest. A picture can be good without being the best match for a particular brief.

Did you give specific suggestions when she first showed it to you, or just say you liked it? If you effectively helped shape the entry, that adds another reason the organizers should have known about the connection.

I wouldn't assume stepping aside was necessary. In a small arts club, judges may know several people who enter. The useful thing could be transparency rather than automatic exclusion.

That's the distinction I'd make too. Let the organizers decide with the relevant information. Quietly deciding you're impartial enough deprives them of that choice, even if your actual scoring was fair.

Join the discussion

More in AITA