Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for going back to fix an undercharge when my friend needed a lift to the station?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend asked me to keep driving to the station. I turned back towards the shop instead, and she missed her train.

I'd promised her a lift and said I needed one quick grocery stop on the way. When we got back into the car, I checked the receipt and saw that one item I'd taken hadn't been charged. I wanted to go straight back and pay for it.

She pointed out that the stop had already taken longer than I'd expected and that there wasn't time to do both. I knew she was trying to catch a particular train to visit her brother. I also knew I'd be passing the same shop the next afternoon.

I said I didn't feel right driving away after noticing the mistake. She said I could put the item aside and sort it out after dropping her off. I didn't ask her to agree to another delay; I just went back.

She caught a later train, which shortened the visit she'd planned. She isn't saying I should have kept the item without paying. She's angry that I treated fixing my shopping problem immediately as more important than the lift I'd promised. AITA for returning as soon as I noticed?

Discussion

5 community replies

YTA for making the choice for her. The disagreement wasn't whether to pay for the item. It was whether your passenger should lose her planned train so you could settle it that minute, despite already expecting to pass the shop again.

Wanting to correct the receipt was reasonable. You could have taken her to the station and then decided how to contact or revisit the shop. She offered you a way to keep your promise without asking you to forget the undercharge.

You warned her about one quick stop, and then that stop ran long. That should have made you more careful with the time left. It didn't give you an open-ended claim on her afternoon.

I'd apologise for the decision to turn back without her agreement, rather than defending it as proof that you're an honest person. Tell her you understand that her plan became the cost of a mistake in your shopping.

Exactly. You can still value correcting an undercharge while regretting the timing. If the apology ends with “but I had to do the right thing,” it leaves her hearing that getting her to the station as promised wasn't a responsibility worth weighing.

Join the discussion

More in AITA