Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for giving my nephew his birthday present after his mother asked me to hold it back?

AITA category photographAITA

My sister asked me to keep my nephew's birthday gift for two weeks. He'd repeatedly broken a household rule, and she had told him presents would wait until he'd completed the consequence she'd set.

I'd promised him a particular book. I don't like making birthday gifts conditional on behavior, so I brought it when I visited anyway. As I was leaving, I handed it to him and said it was still for his birthday.

My sister was there. She didn't take it from him, but afterward said I'd forced her to choose between backing down and confiscating something he'd just happily received. I said I hadn't agreed to make my gift part of a punishment.

She says I could have argued that point with her before involving him. That's true. I knew what she'd asked; I just didn't want to cooperate with it.

AITA for keeping my promise to him even though it contradicted her plan?

Discussion

5 community replies

You could disagree with the punishment without making the child the place where the adults settled it. Handing over the book in front of her created exactly the choice she described.

I understand wanting a birthday present to remain a gift rather than a reward. Tell your sister that plainly before the next occasion, instead of allowing the gift to carry the whole argument.

You also made a promise to him before this consequence arose. That deserves consideration. A conversation about that promise might have led to a different arrangement, rather than simply treating either adult's position as the only one that counted.

I don't think relatives automatically have to administer a parent's chosen punishment. They can decline to participate in withholding their own gifts.

They can say they won't participate. Here the narrator went further and enacted that disagreement through a surprise handover. Giving the sister notice would have let them address the conflict before the nephew was holding the present.

Join the discussion

More in AITA