Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for giving back a scratchcard a coworker put in my birthday card?

AITA category photographAITA

I opened my birthday card in the break room and found a lottery scratchcard inside. I thanked my coworker for the card, then asked him to take the scratchcard back.

He'd previously invited me to join an office lottery group. I'd declined and said I don't enjoy gambling or want to take part. He says this was different because he'd paid for it and I wasn't risking my own money.

I understand that distinction. I still didn't want to scratch it or wait to see whether I'd won something. I said, “Please don't spend money on this for me,” while two colleagues were nearby. He looked embarrassed and said I could have quietly put it aside instead of rejecting a small bit of birthday fun.

I kept the greeting card and thanked him for remembering. He says returning the ticket made it seem as though his gift was morally beneath me. That wasn't what I intended.

AITA for refusing instead of accepting it politely?

Discussion

5 community replies

You'd already said you didn't want to take part. He thought paying for it solved your objection, but your explanation wasn't limited to losing your own money.

Returning it in front of colleagues may have made a small mismatch feel like a public rebuke. You can acknowledge that without changing your answer about future tickets.

A private “I appreciated you remembering my birthday; I don't want gambling gifts, even when someone else pays” would clarify the exact point he misunderstood.

I'd probably have kept it and done nothing with it. That seems kinder than handing back a cheap gift someone intended as fun.

That was an available option, but it could have left him thinking this kind of gift was welcome. The narrator could have delayed the conversation until they were alone; they didn't need to pretend the ticket was something they wanted.

Join the discussion

More in AITA