Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for getting the same small tattoo as my friend after she asked me not to?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend saw my new crescent-moon tattoo and said, “I told you I didn't want us matching.”

She has the same simple design on her ankle. When she showed it to me, I said I'd always liked that shape and might get something similar. She said she'd chosen hers to mark a personal family moment and wanted it to feel like her thing.

I thought matching small moons was too common an idea to reserve between friends. I got mine on my wrist without mentioning the appointment. When she noticed, I said the tattoos meant different things to us.

She says the meaning isn't the only point: she'd asked me not to copy it, and I went ahead while letting her think I'd dropped the idea. I hadn't explicitly promised not to do it. But I also knew another conversation would be uncomfortable.

AITA for getting the design anyway, rather than choosing something different to protect that feeling for her?

Discussion

5 community replies

Choosing your own tattoo and caring about your friend's reaction aren't mutually exclusive. You didn't need her to approve your body, but you knew this exact choice would hurt her and avoided discussing it.

A small moon can have a different meaning to each of you. That doesn't make her feeling about matching imaginary. Don't try to prove she has no reason to be upset simply because the shape is familiar.

The part about no explicit promise sounds like a narrow defence against a broader complaint. You let the conversation end without saying you still intended to get it. She reasonably feels you preferred surprise over disagreement.

I wouldn't offer a dramatic removal or alteration just to win the argument. First be honest that you heard her preference and chose differently. She can decide what that means for the friendship without managing what happens to your wrist.

Agreed. A promise to change it, made only because you're frightened she'll stay angry, could start another resentment. An apology for avoiding the conversation is something you can offer without pretending you never wanted the tattoo.

Join the discussion

More in AITA