Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for ending calls when my friend puts me on speaker in public?

AITA category photographAITA

A stranger answered a joke I'd made to my friend. That was how I discovered I was on speaker while she waited in a shop queue.

I hadn't said anything particularly private that time, but I felt exposed. I've asked before that she tell me if other people can hear our calls. She says I know she makes calls while running errands, so I should assume someone might be nearby.

I told her I'd hang up and we could talk later. Since then, when she says she's using speaker in a public place, I've ended the call politely. She says I'm making it impossible to keep in touch because errands are when she has time to talk.

I'm happy to exchange messages and arrange a call when she's home. She says scheduling every conversation takes away the ease of being friends. AITA for making privacy a condition of talking on the phone?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA. You asked for notice, and now you're choosing whether to continue with that information. That's a reasonable way to handle different preferences.

Keep distinguishing a preference from an accusation. You don't need to say she's a bad friend for using speaker; you can say you don't enjoy having an unknown audience for your side of a conversation.

Not every call needs to be a scheduled event. She could message that she's home and ask whether you have ten minutes. You could also decide there are light conversations you're comfortable having in public, if you want that option.

Anyone could overhear her speaking during an errand anyway. I wonder whether the narrator is expecting a level of privacy a casual phone call can't always provide.

There's still a difference between hearing one nearby person and being able to hear both sides of the call. The narrator isn't asking for a guarantee of secrecy; they're declining a setup that lets strangers respond to them.

Join the discussion

More in AITA