Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for deducting an old debt from a payment my friend accidentally sent twice?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend accidentally sent me $50 twice for tickets I'd bought. We checked together and confirmed the extra payment. She asked for the duplicate $50 back; I returned $30.

I kept $20 because she still owed me that amount for an earlier shared purchase. We'd discussed it before, and she agrees she owes it. I'd reminded her twice and was tired of waiting.

She says I should have returned the mistaken payment in full and asked separately for the older money. I said the result was the same: she no longer owed me $20, and I no longer had her extra $50.

She isn't disputing the arithmetic. She's upset that I decided what the accidental payment would be used for without asking her. I think insisting on two separate transfers is unnecessary when we've agreed on both amounts.

AITA for settling the old amount this way?

Discussion

5 community replies

You settled an acknowledged debt and avoided two separate transfers. I don't think the arithmetic was unfair. The part she had no say in was your deciding to settle it at that moment.

You could have sent one sentence before doing it: “Shall I return $30 and count the other $20 against what you owe?” That would have made the same arithmetic a proposal instead of a surprise.

Her objection doesn't erase the overdue money. If you apologize for acting without checking, also agree on how shared purchases will work next time. You may prefer not to cover them for her.

The accidental payment wasn't an invitation to decide when an unrelated debt would be repaid. I think the narrator should have kept those conversations separate.

I'd usually ask first too. Still, the repeated reminders and her agreement about the amount matter here. It isn't a disputed bill the narrator invented after spotting extra money. The conversation should address both the surprise deduction and why the old payment kept being postponed.

Join the discussion

More in AITA