Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for declining my grandmother's vintage fur coat even though she isn't asking me to buy fur?

AITA category photographAITA

My grandmother offered me her old fur coat. I said it was generous, but I wouldn't wear it.

I don't feel comfortable wearing real fur. She says the coat was made long before I was born, accepting it wouldn't mean ordering a new one, and she'd rather see it used than kept in a wardrobe. I understand why that feels different to her.

She wore it on occasions that matter to her and imagined me making memories in it too. When I said I could appreciate those stories without wearing the coat, she said I was turning a family keepsake into a statement against her.

I hadn't criticized her for owning it or asked her to get rid of it. I also declined her suggestion to take it now and decide later, because I didn't want to accept something I already knew I wouldn't use.

AITA for rejecting a piece of family history over a choice that wouldn't involve me buying anything?

Discussion

5 community replies

You can value her memories without agreeing to wear every object connected with them. Declining before taking it home was more honest than accepting and quietly leaving it unused.

She wanted the coat's story to continue with you. Talk about that loss rather than trying to win an abstract debate about whether accepting old fur counts as supporting new purchases.

You might ask to record her memories of the occasions when she wore it, if she'd enjoy that. Let it be an invitation to hear her stories, not a consolation project she has to accept.

I can understand her distinction. Taking an existing family garment isn't the same action as commissioning a new one.

It is a different action, and the narrator acknowledges that. They can still decide they don't want to wear this garment. Understanding her distinction doesn't require arriving at her preference.

Join the discussion

More in AITA